| 2024-2025 League Champion - Suffolk Sting Runner Up - Naples Kaos  | Steve Brandi | PJ DiMartino | Justin Favalaro | Max Halvorsen | Dan Healy | Brett Jackson | Anthony Koslow | Ted Matos | Billy Pascalli | Dan Perepezko | KJ Tiefenwerth | Jason Muro - HC |
|
| 2023-2024 League Champion - Suffolk Sting Runner Up - Denver Demon Dogs | Natasha Allen
| Steve Brandi
| PJ DiMartino
| Max Halvorsen
| Dan Healy | Brett Jackson | Keith Johnson | Anthony Koslow | Ted Matos | Jordan Mula | Billy Pascalli | KJ Tiefenwerth
| Josh Weger
| Jason Muro - HC | Ted Matos - AC
|
|
 | 2022-2023 League Champion - Denver Demon Dogs Runner Up - Suffolk Sting
| CJ Bateman
| Ruben Dario
| Kevin Dwyer
| Michael Ellis
| Taylor Jay
| Jon Joy
| Jazz Kichline
| Alex Payne
| Kyle Phelps
| CJ Piz
| Wes Schaeffer
| Jake Townsend
| Robb Woods
| Owen Schaeffer - HC |
|
|
 | 2021-2022 League Champion - Suffolk Sting Runner Up - Pittsburgh Inferno
| PJ DiMartino
| Max Halvorsen
| Keith Johnson
| Tyler Kraft
| Anthony Merrigan
| Joey Mula
| Jordan Mula
| Tommy Nostramo
| Billy Pascalli
| Derek Schultz
| Kyla Sanders
| Jason Muro - HC
|
| Anthony Violante - AC
|
|
|
 | 2020-2021 League Champion - Suffolk Sting Runner Up - Philadelphia Liberty
| Joey DiMartino
| PJ DiMartino
| Max Halvorsen
| Brett Jackson
| Keith Johnson
| Tyler Kraft
| Jordan Mula
| Tommy Nostramo
| Matthew O'Shaughnessy
| Billy Pascalli
| KJ Teifenwerth
| Jason Muro - HC
|
| Anthony Violante - AC
|
|
|
 | 2019-20 League Champion - Suffolk Sting Runner Up - Colorado Springs Thunder
|
|
 | 2018-2019 League Champion - Suffolk Sting Runner Up - Colorado Springs Thunder
|
|
 | 2017-2018 League Champion - Suffolk Sting Runner Up - Colorado Springs Thunder
|
|
 | 2016-2017 League Champion - Pittsburgh Inferno Runner Up - Colorado Springs Thunder
|
|
 | 2015-2016 League Champion - Suffolk Sting Runner Up - Colorado Springs Thunder
|
|
 | 2014-2015 League Champion - Marple Gladiators Runner Up - Colorado Springs Thunder
| Ryan Carr
| Scott Cras
| Joe D’Angelantonio
| AJ Ehinger
| JJ Fichter
| Shane Fox
| Matt Grabert
| Eddie Jones
| Mike Longo
| Joe O’Neil
| Tom Youmans
| Mike Casey - HC
|
| John Holmes - AC
|
|
|
 | 2013-2014 League Champion - Marple Gladiators Runner Up - Parker Prowlers
| Nick Allison
| Ryan Carr
| Scott Cras
| Joe D’Angelantonio
| Jim Devine
| PJ DiMartino
| AJ Ehinger
| JJ Fichter
| Shane Fox
| Eddie Jones
| Mike Longo
| Jon Lucente
| Mike Maczynski | Joe O’Neil
| Tom Youmans
| Mike Casey - HC
| John Holmes - AC
|
|
|
 | 2012-2013 League Champion - Long Island Snipers Runner Up - Colorado Springs Thunder
| Travis Bokina
| Mike Genova
| John Healy
| Mike Hewkin
| Sean Kearney
| Joe Mazzie
| Jonathan Mosenson
| Brendan Nelson
| Anthony Pagano
| Pete Pennecke
| John Pinheiro
| Rowan Porter
| Greg Thompson
| Tim McManus - HC
| Jason Muro - AC
|
|
 | 2011-2012 League Champion - Suffolk Sting Runner Up - Parker Prowlers
| Travis Bokina
| Ryan Carey
| Nick Diamasi
| John Healy
| John McGuinness
| Jonathan Mosenson
| Anthony Pagano
| Pete Pennecke
| John Petito
| Rowan Porter
| JP Susco
| Greg Thompson
| Jason Muro - HC
| Tim McManus - AC
|
|
|
 | 2010-2011 League Champion - St. Louis Snipers Runner Up - Suffolk Sting
| Joe Altaether
| Travis Bokina
| Dustin Brown
| Adam Clarke
| Shawn Gawrys
| Tyler Glueck
| Cody Kettler
| Justin Maroon
| Phil Maroon
| Zack Reis
| Matt Sexton
| Jeremy McCoy - HC
|
|
 | 2009-2010 League Champion - Colorado Springs Thunder Runner Up - New Jersey Grizzlies
| Eric Bogenrief
| Mike Gipson
| Nick Gonneila
| Bryan Higney
| Dan Lamb
| Branden Maytum
| Jake Miller
| Sean Pearson
| Matt Pedersen
| Ryan Pedersen
| Josh Serby
| Jesse Tuttle
| Brian Yingling
| CJ Yoder
| Jami Yoder
|
| Dave Needham - HC
|
|
|
 | 2008-2009 League Champion - Colorado Springs Thunder Runner Up - Connecticut Blaze
| Bob Birdno
| Eric Bogenrief
| Mike Ciolli
| Shane Hayden
| Bryan Higney
| Dan Lamb
| Branden Maytum
| Matt Pedersen
| Ryan Pedersen
| James Risenhoover
| Aaron Towns
| Jesse Tuttle
| Brian Yingling
| CJ Yoder
| Dave Needham - HC
|
|
 | 2007-2008 League Champion - Phoenix Dragons Runner Up - Connecticut Blaze
| Chad Chapman
| Alex Dodt
| Josh Joles
| Duane Jones
| Tyler Koressel
| Josh Laricchia
| Danny Marmorstein
| Justin Maroon
| Cody O’Reilly
|
| Dave Marmorstein (HC)
|
|
|
 | 2006-2007 League Champion - Boston Roller Rats Runner Up - Southside Snipers
| Gerrard Cioffi
| Jeff Goulet
| Darrell Interbartolo
| Tony King
| Roger Lee
| Dan Liberty
| Jay McGeown
| Rodney Millette
| Pete Pennecke
| Paul Rogers
| Glen Squillacioti
| Scott St. Cyr
| Mike Whitney
| Ed Whitney - HC
|
|
|
 | 2006 League Champion - Philadelphia Growl Runner Up - Littleton Fire
| Bob Beauchamp
| Mike Catalano
| Joe D’Aloisio
| JD Davidson
| Brian Fischer
| Jason Kalish
| Bill Katinsky
| Ray Katinsky
| Mike Keating
| John Pinheiro
| Mike Sanchez
| Sean Sullivan
| Ron Tracy
| Jim Vivona
| Anthony Flynn - HC
|
| Mark Yudell - AC
|
|
|
 | 2005 League Champion - Philadelphia Growl Runner Up - York Typhoon
| Meaty Aksalic
| Bob Beauchamp
| JD Davidson
| Jason Kalish
| Bill Katinsky
| Ray Katinsky
| Dan Lenza
| Justin Nazarenko
| John Pinheiro
| Mike Sanchez
| Sean Sullivan
| Ron Tracy
| Jim Vivona
| Jason Yocum
| Anthony Flynn - HC
|
|
 | 2004 League Champion - York Tour Typhoon Runner Up - Morristown Minutemen | Tom Brubaker
| Shane Byrd
| Brian Fleury
| Geoff Finch
| Matt Matincheek
| Matt Morris
| Shawn Powell
| Denis Robichaud
| Kevin Spain
| Jimmy Staub
| Mike Staub
| Zach Strausbaugh
| Frank Szilagyi
| Brian Yingling
| Steve Yingling
| CJ Yoder
| Kean Quinton - HC
| Dave Kelly - AC
|
|
 | 2003 League Champion - York Tour Typhoon Runner Up - Nexed Nasty Boyz | Tom Brubaker
| Shane Byrd
| Jason Campbell
| Geoff Finch
| Brian Fluery
| Cheryl Morgan
| Matt Morris
| Kevin Spain
| Zach Strausbaugh
| Jimmy Staub
| Frank Szilagyi
| Brian Yingling
| Steve Yingling
| Brandon Yoder
| CJ Yoder
| Kean Quinton - HC
| Dave Kelly - AC
|
|
|
 | 2002 League Champion - York Tour Typhoon Runner Up - Marple Mission Gladiators | Tom Brubaker
| Chad Burger
| Shane Byrd
| Geoff Finch
| Cheryl Morgan
| Matt Morris
| Dave Stauffer
| Zach Strausbaugh
| Frank Sziragyi
| Ken Ulerick
| Steve Yingling
| Brian Yingling
| Brandon Yoder
| CJ Yoder
| Kean Quinton (HC)
|
| Dave Kelly (AC)
|
|
|