Awards Archive: 2012 - 2016
2012
| AWARD | WINNER | TEAM |
| Pro League Most Valuable Player | JT Bovee | Parker Prowlers |
| Pro Top Scorer | John McGuiness | Suffolk Sting |
| Pro Most Valuable Goaltender | Robb Woods | Parker Prowlers |
| Pro Playoff Most Valuable Player | Greg Thompson | Suffolk Sting |
| Unsung Hero | Frank Caldwell | Pottstown Rolling Relics |
| Coach of the Year | Jason Muro | Suffolk Sting |
| Organization of the Year | Suffolk Sting |
2013
| AWARD | WINNER | TEAM |
| Pro League Most Valuable Player | Kyle Phelps | Parker Prowlers |
| Pro Top Scorer | Nate Gerger | Pittsburgh Inferno |
| Pro Most Valuable Goaltender | Mike Genova | Long Island Snipers |
| Pro Playoff Most Valuable Player | Mike Genova | Long Island Snipers |
| Unsung Hero | Denis Jelcic | New Jersey Grizzlies |
| Coach of the Year | John Bovee | Parker Prowlers |
| Organization of the Year | Pittsburgh Inferno |
2014
| AWARD | WINNER | TEAM |
| Pro League Most Valuable Player | Mike Keating | Hershey Typhoon |
| Pro Top Scorer | CJ Yoder | Colorado Springs Thunder |
| Pro Most Valuable Goaltender | Mike Maczynski | Marple Gladiators |
| Pro Playoff Most Valuable Player | AJ Ehringer | Marple Gladiators |
| Unsung Hero | Dave Needman | |
| Coach of the Year | Mike Casey | Marple Gladiators |
| Organization of the Year | Colorado Springs Thunder |
2015
| AWARD | WINNER | TEAM |
| Pro League Most Valuable Player | Nate Gerger | Pittsburgh Inferno |
| Pro Top Scorer | Jake Miller | Colorado Springs Thunder |
| Pro Most Valuable Goaltender | Robb Woods | Parker Prowlers |
| Pro Playoff Most Valuable Player | Shane Fox | Marple Gladiators |
| Unsung Hero | Jay Mazer | Harrisburg Lunatics |
| Coach of the Year | Rick Murchek | Omaha Outlaws |
| Organization of the Year | Colorado Springs Thunder |
2016
| AWARD | WINNER | TEAM |
| Pro League Most Valuable Player | Derrick Burnett | Colorado Springs Thunder |
| Pro Top Scorer | Josh Serby | Ft Collins Catz |
| Pro Most Valuable Goaltender | Mike Maczynski | Marple Gladiators |
| Pro Playoff Most Valuable Player | John McGuiness | Suffolk Sting |
| Unsung Hero | Josh Ingrum | |
| Coach of the Year | Jason Muro | Suffolk Sting |
| Organization of the Year | Suffolk Sting |