| 2010 | Geoff Finch | York Typhoon |
| 2013 | Brian Fischer | Philadelphia Growl
Labeda Lawdawgs |
| 2016 | Sean Sullivan | Philadelphia Growl
St Louis Cobras |
| 2019 | Jim Vivona | Philadelphia Growl
Morristown Minutemen |
| 2020 | Josh Laricchia | Phoenix Dragons |
| 2021 | Pete Pennecke | Suffolk Sting
LI 495ers
Boston Swamp Rats |
| 2022 | Brian Yingling | York Typhoon
Parker Prowlers
CS Thunder |
| 2022 | Steve Yingling | York Typhoon
Harrisburg Lunatics |
| 2023 | Kyle Gouge | Midwest Tornados |
| 2023 | Jeff Goulet | CT Blaze |
| 2023 | Dan Lamb | CS Thunder |
| 2024 | Joe D'Aloisio | Philadelphia Growl |
| 2024 | James Manganaro | ISCA Grizzlies |
| 2024 | Matt Turner | West Minster Blizzard |
